Kenny’s Dinner Club selection this month came with the following preamble:
“The last attempt at an organic restaurant left more than something to be desired. The last time good pie was promised, that came up a little short too. This time we’ll try again to tackle them both again at the same time. But keeping in accordance with voting rules, voting will be based on the main meal — the pie is just a bonus.”

Aphrodite’s Cafe has strange decoration. Is it Harry Potter?
The organic restaurant he was referring to was Organic Lives (score 2.5 / 6) and the pie reference was from Acme Café (score 5 / 5). In an attempt to redeem organic foods, Kenny chose Aphrodite’s Café & Pie Shop on 4th Avenue and I’ve got mixed feelings about it.
Under our normal voting guidelines, Dinner Club reviews do not consider dessert. At Aphrodite’s though, we had to reconsider this for two reasons: the meals we ordered were set menus that included desserts (ie dessert was part of what the restaurant considered a meal, and not an additional item that could be overlooked), and the word “pie” was included in the restaurant’s name (we all ordered different pies for dessert).
During the Dinner Club voting process, Kenny and Phil usually think about whether they would return to the restaurant a second time, while Ang considers value and atmosphere to be part of her voting criteria. I’ve always based my vote strictly on the food under the logic that if the food isn’t any good, I wouldn’t return a second time. I also don’t believe in tainting a vote with consideration of atmosphere unless that atmosphere includes something unhygienic. And when it comes to value, I’ve never really had to consider it before because most of our Dinner Club selections have been relatively affordable. This month’s restaurant choice was an exception. At $45.50 per person (after taxes and 18% mandatory gratuity for parties of six or more) for a mediocre meal that left me and Kenny hungry within an hour, I had to change what would’ve been a half-vote to a full thumbs down.
Dinner Club: Aphrodite’s Café & Pie Shop

Ann enjoying the bread
Of the six of us, five ordered from the Dinner Fresh Sheet which is updated regularly to work with seasonal ingredients and holidays. Since it was Thanksgiving weekend here in Canada, there was a Roasted Turkey with Wild Rice-Pumpkin Chevre Stuffing & Herb Gravy dish, which is what I ordered (sounds good, right?). Morten and Ang both ordered the Beef Bourguignon with Egg Noodles. Ann and Phil ordered the Garlic Roasted Eggplant with Mashed Pumpkin & Mushroom Ragout. And Kenny ordered a Turkey Pot Pie from the regular menu with a side of house soup (duck). Each of our Dinner Fresh Sheet entrées included either a soup or meadow side salad to start, and a pie for dessert. Ann chose a salad which she enjoyed, while the rest of us chose either the caramelized leek and lentil soup or the duck house special of the day.
The caramelized leek and lentil soup was thick and ordinary, if not a bit bland, and took about a half hour to arrive. The duck soup though, was an utter disappointment. After taking our orders, our server had brought baskets of yummy hearty bread and butter so I had taken it as an indication that subsequent dishes would be just as nutritious, hearty and flavourful. The duck soup was watery, the meat was dry, and the overall taste was sour. It was edible, but tasted like something you made at home and decided wasn’t good enough to serve as a main but would be acceptable as an addition to the meal. Not great.
After we finished our starters, we waited for another half hour at our awkwardly small table where Ang had to saddle a table leg and Ann and I were constantly trying to avoid being knocked by Morten’s knees. I thought that perhaps the waiting was part of the overall experience the restaurant was going for, but even the bill took forever to arrive!

My turkey entree; that black thing in the front is the one piece of burnt turkey skin
When the entrées finally made their appearance, they did so in style. The dishes looked great! My first bite of turkey was tender and moist, but there was very little gravy flavour. I learned over the next two bites that the red cabbage was sour, bitter, and not worth plating. I started to pick out all the cabbage bits, and it turned out that about a fourth of the dish was cabbage and carrots, while there were only two small pieces of turkey and one burnt piece of turkey skin in the entire dish. The burnt turkey piece was completely black, but tasty in a deliciously cancerous way. The second piece of turkey was dry and unseasoned. The worst part though, was the potato. I love mashed potatoes. I don’t understand how you can mess up mashed potatoes. They messed up mashed potatoes!! The potato wasn’t cooked enough so the mash retained its original rectangular form, and they didn’t bother putting any garlic or herbs in it so it was boring just like the turkey.

Kenny’s tortured look for “there’s too much pepper in this dish”
Ang and Morten were also a bit disappointed in their Beef Bourguignon which they likened to a tangy pulled pork (with beef instead of pork) on slippery noodles. I tried a bite and agreed with Ang that it had a sour twinge to it like the soup and the cabbage. Ann didn’t like the eggplant dish she ordered, so she traded it with Kenny for his turkey pot pie. The verdict on the pot pie was “good”, but Kenny also had complaints about the eggplant dish. He said it had been pre-seasoned with too much pepper and his taste buds were taking a beating (my words, not his — I think he compared it to setting his mouth on fire). Phil had ordered the same dish, but didn’t taste any pepper in his. Either someone’s taste buds are way off, or somebody in the kitchen wasn’t paying attention.
And this is where the voting got tricky for me. My main entrée wasn’t as bad as a skewer from Nine Dishes or a plate of ribs from Memphis Blues, but it wasn’t as good as chicken from Afghan Chopan or veggie pakora from Green Lettuce. It was edible and nicely plated, but the first and last bites were very different on the taste-scale. I would have to base my final decision on the pie.
We ordered Apple Pie, Blackberry Apple Pie, Raspberry Rhubarb Pie, Pumpkin Pie, and Chocolate Pecan Pie for dessert. Kenny liked the apple pie, Phil enjoyed his blackberry apple pie, Ann really liked her pumpkin pie, Ang thought the pumpkin pie wasn’t any better than the kind you get from Save-On-Foods, both Ang and I thought Morten got the best pie (Chocolate Pecan) though he didn’t seem to think it was especially good, and I had a tough time finishing my Raspberry Rhubarb Pie because it was so friggin’ SOUR! This was the tipping point. I might love mashed potatoes, but I REALLY love pie. And I really didn’t even LIKE this pie. I actually left some of it on the plate!

Aphrodite’s Cafe: Blackberry Apple Pie
Kenny brought up the fact that the pie crust was missing a key ingredient: salt. Everyone agreed. Ang thought the crust was too “doughy” and though that wouldn’t be my word of choice, I get what she meant. The crust felt unfinished, as if it was missing ingredients and hadn’t been baked long enough. That was it. You can mess up turkey and be forgiven. Same with mashed potato if it’s not one of the key components of a dish. But under no circumstance can you have the word “Pie” in your name and serve terrible pie! That’s unforgivable. Simply unforgivable. Thumbs down!
Sidenote: For those that think I should’ve voted with a half thumb score, I’d like to mention that Ang would like to change her previous thumbs up vote to a half thumb as a result of the end bill ($45.50 per person) which she hadn’t looked at until today because Morten had paid with his credit card. The general consensus was that the meals we consumed couldn’t justify the amount we paid for them no matter how organic the ingredients were.

Aphrodite’s Cafe & Pie Shop: 4.5 out of 6
Overall Food Group Rating: 4.5 out of 6
The Good: The dishes were nicely presented and the service was at least friendly, if not efficient. Ang also noted that she felt better knowing that the ingredients were organic.
The Bad: Most of the dishes had a sourness to them. The vegetables they used were fresh and you could tell they had potential to make a great meal, but there’s something (or someone) missing in the kitchen…
The Ugly: The washroom has the weirdest set-up. It’s a tiny little closet of a room to begin with, but rather than mounting the toilet against a wall (like most people do) they placed it smack dab in the middle of the floor. I had to sit sideways on the seat and my nose was still inches from the wall. Very awkward.